It is at this point we need to be careful. Far too many
people want to make this political, railing against parties, ownership
rights, politicians and business as if screaming slogans in the echo
chamber of social media and giving cosy fireside chats to agenda driven
media will clean up our rivers. It will not. It will drive reasonable
people to stop listening and alienate those who have their hands on the
levers of power.
Let us start with parties because this should not become a
shrill Conservative party bad, everyone else good polemic. I have
researched this enough, going all the way back to Victorian times, to tell
you this not about who you vote for – they are rarely any votes in s**t.
Nor is it about private vs. public provision. The record in Wales, mostly
nationalised and Scotland, all nationalised is no better than England. In
England, where in the post war era we have been from private, to public and
then back to private ownership the record has been one of consistent
decline. In fact, if you really want to get on a high horse, it is readily
arguable that the 21st century privatisation mess was inherited
from the 20th century
nationalisation car crash.
As to the argument that all the ills of the water and
sewerage industry may be laid at the door of rampant capitalism I have to
aver. It is a low return investment in a heavily regulated sector. Of
course, plenty ramp up the rhetoric by talking about £60 billion in
dividends (aka profits) since privatisation but when you get all granular
about those sort of numbers it is a profit of just £1.35 per household per
week since privatisation.
I know many of the recent announcements by our gang of five
such as banning wet wipes and power showers have been much derided and to a
certain extent, like the banning of drinking straws to save the planet, I
agree. Likewise, some of the spending pledges ware woefully inadequate and
the rhetoric woolly.
However, I’ll bet
that if you sat down with any of the five for an off-the-record chat they’d
agree with my ‘woefully inadequate’ summation. And that is where we have
won the first battle. A year or two ago they would have all tried to
deflect. Say things were not that bad. Today there is no hiding from the
facts by anyone.
Next time I’ll tell you how we can win the war.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment