Friday 2 February 2024

We fought Southern Water and we won

 

Greetings!

 

Punk band The Clash were right about most things but for once they were wrong: you can fight the law and the law will not win. A band of Hampshire river keepers proved this last week when they squared up to Southern Water to eventually overturn plans to pump 2.5 million litres of raw sewage into the upper reaches of the River Test. However, before I tell you how they did it let me take you back a few steps in the process of what is rather innocently called ‘overpumping’.

 

As you will well know much of Britain is served by a sewage management system that was built to cope for a nation as it was in the 1970’s when the population was 20 million fewer and water consumption on a per head basis about half of what it is today. Combine that with a built environment that has turned roads and housing into giant, continuous funnels and you have a sewage system that becomes overwhelmed by rainfall that would have dispersed without comment or incident 50 years ago.

 

 

As the Duke of Wellington said addressing the gathered troops on the eve of the Battle of Waterloo: I don't know how the enemy will see you but you scare the hell out of me.

 

Overpuming is what water companies, faced with all the above, do when their sewage systems are unable to cope with the volume of wastewater in the pipes, pumps and plants. To overpump they apply for a permit from the Environment Agency to flush the excess away, untreated but usually dilute sewage, into the nearest river or convenient water course. In the case of the River Test, the ‘overpump’ was from the village of Longparish which is just north of where the river crosses under the A303 east of Andover, Hampshire. It was to be an unusually egregious form of overpumping with the necessity to lay hundreds of metres of temporary pipe from village to river and the digging of a temporary settlement tank enroute (largely pointless and there for optics not effectiveness) before the waste was poured into the River Test.

 

Here are the three things you need to know about overpumping. Firstly, it has been going on forever but largely under the radar. All those You Tubes clips of last year that showed the outpouring of millions of gallons of waste for hundreds of thousands of hours are the most visible evidence of institutional dumping. However, public awareness has turned the spotlight on the practice which I suspect would have gone unnoticed a decade ago. Secondly, the water companies do not have any real incentive to deal with the issue because it is a good deal cheaper than the alternatives, namely upgrading the infrastructure and actually treating the waste. Ironically, the more degraded the pipe network the better for them as the waste seeps, unseen, into the ground. However, this out-of-sight-out-of-mind strategy gets upended in wet weather years as the water table rises to the same level of the pipes thus eliminating ‘helpful’ seepage. Incidentally, most of the same logic applies to septic tanks for private homes not on main drainage. Finally, the planning system as currently configured will only make the situation worse. Let me tell you the madness of it all.

 

Now, if you or I were building a family home in an area without mains drainage we would have to install a self-sufficient, private waste treatment plant at a cost of tens of thousands of pounds that would have to fulfil vigorous environmental regulation. If we were a developer building a thousand home estate we would equally have to comply with stringent rules, not least in separating the rainfall water from roads, roofs and run off from the home waste, with separate pipe systems for each. Now this is the way of the future by avoiding commingling of the large volume of largely harmless rainwater with the undesirable output from homes and businesses. However, and this is the madness of our planning system, having gone to all the effort and expense of separating the two, guess where both end up? Yes, the law obliges the water company to let us, the developer, connect both waste pipes to the same main drainpipe! 

 

 

You could not make it up but back to our band of river keepers. Thanks to a brief, but sustained, blitz on the local media, supported by the Test and Itchen Association and locals MPs, the gathering of thirty or more river keepers by the Test in Longparish last Friday, the day the overpumping was due to start, made for headline news with TV crews and press. By some strange quirk of fate neither Environment Agency nor Southern Water representatives attended, preferring a brief press release saying the situation was now ‘under review’ with the plans for over pumping entirely abandoned on Monday.

 

It is a great victory for activism following on from something similar in the summer of 2022 when Southern Water tried to increase abstraction capacity from the River Test at the height of the drought. I am convinced these fights will become more frequent by necessity as our water system falters further under the strains of aging infrastructure and the ever increasing demands on it. Hundreds of billions are required to save us from our own waste but even if we started today (LOL) the fights will need to continue for a decade or more.

 

 

Richard Slocock: a chalkstream life

 

I did not realise how much I would miss Richard Slocock until I started writing to bring you news of his sad death from cancer on 20 January. No more of those calls which usually started with the words, “You are not going to believe this Simon …..” which would lead us into some lengthy conversation about the latest madness from the Environment Agency or some busybody body that purport to know the chalkstreams better than those who have spent most of their working lives on them.

 

For Richard was one of those people, a man who began way back in the 1980’s when his Wessex Chalk Streams, which focussed on the Frome and Piddle, took up where Dermot Wilson here at Nether Wallop Mill left off. Richard’s business at Lawrences Farm in the Dorset village Tolpuddle of martyr fame, was the most fully rounded operation that I do not recall anyone coming close to replicating. You could stay, you could rent beats, there was the trout lake for teaching and a tackle store from which Richard dispensed advice, though in truth not all of it cheerful.

 

Richard, and I say this without a hint of criticism, was never one to talk up the prospects for your day ahead. Maybe it was some cunning reverse psychology on his part but whether it was or was not it certainly worked as he was never short of clients and was still going strong last season despite his illness.

 

 

Richard and Simon laughing about who knows what ......

 

Richard was passionate about chalkstreams and fly fishing long before it was fashionable to be such a person. He campaigned in many guises including as Chairman of the Frome & Piddle Association and created the guiding and teaching body REFFIS as a commonsense antidote to some of the other, shall we say effete, fly fishing organisations. He was also one of the founding forces behind the Wild Trout Trust though it must be said he rather felt the Trust had lost its way in more recent years.

 

I will miss Richard greatly; he was a huge friend to me from when I was wet behind the ears in this business both as a source of advice and good humour. As Lord Tennyson wrote of The Brook, “For men may come and men may go, But I go on forever.” I hope that part of Richard’s legacy will be that that is indeed true of our precious chalkstreams.

 

 

Time flies

 

Times flies …… it will soon be time to step out on to the riverbank for a new season. Just now that looks like it will be a very soggy bank but hey, though a wet winter is not without its challenges, I am not one to complain about too much water.

 

Certainly, it truncated the grayling season, with barely any opportunities since Christmas. Likewise, many of the restoration and repair projects we had planned this winter are now on hold to 2024/25. My advice is check those wellies do not leak and take a long handled net.

 

Looking ahead to the coming session we have not been able to put some diaries fully online; more news on that in a 2024 Update Special next week that will contain exciting news of fishing in Cumbria, County Durham, the Lake District and Yorkshire and not just trout.

 

 

 

 

A tale of three rivers top to bottom: Kimbridge (Test), Dunbridge (Dun) and Bullington Manor (Dever).

 

 

Quiz

 

The normal random collection of questions inspired by the date, events or topics in the Newsletter. It is just for fun with answers at the bottom of the page.

 

1)     Who was buried in St. George's Chapel at Windsor Castle on this day in 1901?

 

2)     How many no. 1 hits did The Clash have?

 

3)     Lord Alfred Tennyson followed who as Poet Laureate in 1850?

 

 

Have a good Six Nations weekend.



Best wishes,

 

 

Simon Cooper simon@fishingbreaks.co.uk

Founder & Managing Directorwww.fishingbreaks.co.uk

 

 

Quiz answers:

 

1)     Queen Victoria

2)     None. The best was no. 2 in the UK charts with Rock the Casbah in 1982

3)     William Wordsworth

No comments:

Post a Comment